The BCCR FTI project

Model framework for consistent estimation of climate sensitivity and ocean heat content

Partners:
NORCE: Thomas Toniazzo, Odd Helge Otterå, Aleksi Nummelin, Bjørg Risebrobakken, Chuncheng Guo, Elaine McDonagh
UiB: Eirik Vinje Galaasen
NERSC: Yanchun He

NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Background/Motivation:

  • Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS) is an uncertain factor that integrates the various processes in the climate system into one policy relevant number, e.g., 1.5 C warming given certain CO emission.
  • A significant source of uncertainty in model-based estimates of climate sensitivity is associated with ocean heat content (OHC) and how that will increase as the stratification changes under global warming.
    • Depends on both local ocean processes and ocean-atmosphere coupling biases
  • To reduce the uncertainty, we test a partial coupling method, which can be used in modern and paleo context to derive self-consistent estimates of ECS and OHC.
  • The approach:
    • first takes the observed SST into a slab ocean
    • then couples an atmospheric model with the slab ocean model to derive an atmospheric state that is in balance with the given SST field. The simulated local air-sea surface fluxes are recorded over a climatic period
    • the air-sea fluxes are used to drive an ocean general circulation model towards equilibrium.
  • Potential benifits:
    • this method is self-consistent, conserves heat, and avoids coupled biases and related feedbacks.
  • The objective:
    • To test how far from the original SSTs will the forced ocean model drift due to circulation biases,
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Model setup:

  • Slab ocean control run (70 years) -> calculated Q-flux
    • Slab ocean (docn)+CAM+CICE+river runoff?
    • run for 70 years
  • Slab ocean run -> save coupled fluxes
    • the last 20 years is used
  • Ocean-ice model simulation forced with coupler fluxes
    • one experiment with salinity restoration
      • run for 40 years (2 cycles)
    • without salinity restoration
      • run for 120 years (6 cycles)
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Slab ocean setup descriptions

(updated, 23 Nov 2022)

The method: calculating the ocean heat transport (Q-fluxes) by relaxing slab ocean SST towards observed SST climatology.

Formulation:

  • : estimate of the observed annual mean mixed layer ocean depth (not changed)
  • has a typical time scale of ~15 days
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project
air-sea heat flux (positive down) in cam-slab ocean setup air-sea heat flux minus Q-flux
heat flux heat flux
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Global Averages

3D temp 3D saln SST SSS
temp salinity SST SSS
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Overturning circulation, volume transport

AMOC 26.5N Bering strait Florida Current Drake Passage
AMOC265N bering florida current drake passage
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Temperature/Salnity anomalies

Temperature@0m Salnity@0m MLD
temperature salinity MLD
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Freshwater budget (Salt flux)

net salt flux received by ocean with minus w/o salinity relaxation
salt flux salt flux
salt relaxation flux--> salt restoration
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Freshwater budget (eva, prec, runoff, etc)

net freshwater received by ocean with salinity relaxation with minus w/o salinity relaxation
freshwater flux freshwater flux
salt flux (with minus w/o salinity relaxation)--> salt restoration
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

heat budget (net shortwave,longwave, latent and sensible heat)

net heat flux received by ocean with salinity relaxation with minus w/o salinity relaxation
heat flux heat flux
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

comparisions: net heat flux, net freshwater budget and evaporation difference

net hflx (to ocean) with salinity relaxation hflx with minus w/o salinity relaxation
net heat flux heat flux diff
net freshwater budget evaporation difference
fresh water evaporation flux
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Plan for the next?

  • Plan 1 (almost done)

    • extend the simulation with salinity relaxation (up to 120 years)
    • start new simulation with only salinity relaxation north of 45N.
  • Plan 2

    • Save the SST from the slab ocean (So_t) (on-going)
    • Substitue the SST in ocean-ice simulation with the Slab ocean SST (So_t) to calculate the (latent) heat flux and evaporation.
  • Plan 3 (will not explore now)

    • Save the real flux between the coupler and ocean (Faox stream files in the coupler)
      • some issues handling the air - sea ice fluxes
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Thanks, this is the last slide!

NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Slab ocean setup descriptions (old)

Two approaches

  1. CAM-SOM ("old" way)

The method: calculating the ocean heat transport (Q-fluxes) from an existing CAM simulation with prescribed SST, sea ice extent, and thickness.
Key point: reproduce the observed climate.
Formulation:

  • : estimate of the observed annual mean mixed layer ocean depth
  • change in the sea surface temperature
  • surface net energy balance obtained from a control CAM simulation ().

update: correct to have globa lbalanced flux
Drawbacks:

  • Q-fluxes are dominated by the model climate biases?
  • missing information of fluxes between the ice and ocean
    • an additional flux was added, given an estimate of ice-fraction from a thermodynamic-only sea ice model
NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Slab ocean setup descriptions (old)

Two approaches

  1. CCSM-SOM ("new" way)

The method: calculating the ocean heat transport (Q-fluxes) from an existing CAM simulation with prescribed SST, sea ice extent, and thickness.
Key points:

  • reproduce the coupled climate of the model (,as opposed to the observed climate)
  • use full sea-ice model (CICE)
  • fully-conservative information about ice-ocean fluxes
    Formulation:

Advantage: , , and from a fully-coupled simulation instead of being based on an estimated mixed-layer depth from observations

NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

SOM control run:

Model output
/projects/NS2345K/noresm/thomas/CMIP6/SOM/QS/out/SOj09_hdxpt/cnt_cpldiags

Diagnostics:
http://ns2345k.web.sigma2.no/diagnostics/noresm/yanchun/SOj09_hdxpt/

NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022
The BCCR FTI project

Ocean-ice run with coupler flux:

NERSC CDP group meeting, 2nd Dec 2022

footer: Discussion, 21 Nov 2022 backgroundImage: url('https://flevix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/bubble-animated-background.svg') backgroundImage: url('https://flevix.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Live-Background-1.svg') backgroundImage: url('http://ns2345k.web.sigma2.no/people/yanchun/output/FTI2022/html/bccr/bccr_bg_16v9v2.png') This does not work backgroundImage: url('file:///nird/home/yanchun/ftp/bccr/bccr_bg_16v9v2.png')