Model version I (left) vs. Model version II (right)

Presenting annual means from the following simulations:

Both ModI and ModII are featureCAM5-OsloDevelopment_trunk2.0-6 set up with MG1.5, CLM4.5, and online DMS/POM,

using compset NUDGEPTAEROUPD1

ModI (years 18-19) is from self-nudged simulations (UVPS), commit d4fe4b0, while

ModII (years 2012-2014) is from ERA nudged simulations (UVPS), with main code from commit 64d68619

+ new code for tuning of OM/OC and DUST emissions (now present in commit cdaeb5e)

I.e., the changes from ModI to ModII are: nudging to ERA instead of CAM5-Oslo meteorology, and new tuning for POM and DUST.

ModI PD: CAM5-Oslo, 2000 emissions, 5 years spin-up, self-nudged

ModI PI: CAM5-Oslo, 1850 emissions, 5 years spin-up, self-nudged

ModII PD: CAM5-Oslo, 2000 emissions, 11 years spin-up, nudged to ERA (2001-2015)

ModII PI: CAM5-Oslo, 1850 emissions, 11 years spin-up, nudged to ERA (2001-2015)

Known bugs/shortcomings:

* Condensation/coagulation sink is function of dry size


Emissions

Zonally averaged mass mixing ratios

Zonally averaged mode parameters

Burdens

Effective dry aerosol radii

Particular Matter (PM) concentrations (CAM5-Oslo vs. CAM5-Oslo only)

Wet to total deposition ratios

Lifetimes

RH, cloud properties and precipitation

Cloud droplet properties

Angstrom coefficient, aerosol optical depth, SSA and G

Aerosol optical depth for each species

Mass extinction coefficients for each species

Anthropogenic (PD - PI) aerosol and cloud/RH fields

Radiative forcings at top of the atmosphere

Radiative fluxes at top of the atmosphere


Mass budget numbers for ModI and ModII

(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SO2 total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 65.032, 65.032
(0)	SO2 total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 96.976, 96.379
(0)	SO2 total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 96.864, 96.292
(0)	SO2 burden            (Tg)                = 0.350, 0.354
(0)	SO2 wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 18.966, 19.347
(0)	SO2 lifetime          (d)                 = 1.318, 1.340
(0)	SO2 chemical loss     (%)                 = 58.915, 58.134
(0)	SO2 pct of chem loss in clear air (%)     = 23.871, 24.820
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SO4 total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 1.667, 1.667
(0)	SO4 total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 58.751, 57.689
(0)	SO4 total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 58.446, 57.404
(0)	SO4 burden            (Tg)                = 0.566, 0.568
(0)	SO4 wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 83.289, 83.261
(0)	SO4 lifetime          (d)                 = 3.533, 3.610
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	BC total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 7.928, 7.928
(0)	BC total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 7.928, 7.928
(0)	BC total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 7.910, 7.920
(0)	BC burden            (Tg)                 = 0.100, 0.107
(0)	BC wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 73.505, 72.413
(0)	BC lifetime          (d)                  = 4.621, 4.921
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	POM total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 58.497, 86.923
(0)	POM total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 141.812, 174.386
(0)	POM total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 141.417, 173.943
(0)	POM burden            (Tg)                = 1.835, 2.475
(0)	POM wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 83.304, 82.507
(0)	POM lifetime          (d)                 = 4.735, 5.193
(0)	POM chem prod from MSA (Tg/yr)            = 9.147, 8.943
(0)	POM chem prod (total) (Tg/yr)             = 83.317, 87.464
(0)	POM chem prod terpenes (Tg /yr)           = 74.170, 78.521
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SS total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 1994.136, 1931.745
(0)	SS total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 1994.136, 1931.745
(0)	SS total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 1993.230, 1930.753
(0)	SS burden            (Tg)                 = 5.723, 5.687
(0)	SS wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 56.883, 56.261
(0)	SS lifetime          (d)                  = 1.048, 1.075
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	DU total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 2629.641, 2866.163
(0)	DU total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 2629.641, 2866.163
(0)	DU total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 2626.705, 2866.006
(0)	DU burden            (Tg)                 = 13.657, 18.147
(0)	DU wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 19.062, 23.706
(0)	DU lifetime          (d)                  = 1.898, 2.311
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------