Model version I (left) vs. Model version II (right)

Presenting annual means from simulations woth the following casenames:

ModI = PD-opticsINSITU
ModII = optINSITUnRemote

Model versions are before and after various bugfixes (hygroscopicity og coating, etc.), as well as
some bugs related to diffucsion coefficients and aerosol dry deposition for process tracers.
Also, the accumulation vs. coarse Dust emission ratios have been retuned to the original values.

Both ModI and ModII are featureCAM5-OsloDevelopment_trunk2.0-6 set up with MG1.5, CLM4.5, and online DMS/POM,
using compset NUDGEPTAEROUPD1

ModI (year 2010) is from ERA nudged simulations (UVPS), commit id: e27db49

ModII (year 2010) is from ERA nudged simulations (UVPS), commit id: 7a33fb7

ModI PD: CAM5.3-Oslo, 2000 emissions, 2 years spin-up, nudged to ERA (2008-2010)

ModI PI: CAM5.3-Oslo, 1850 emissions, 2 years spin-up, nudged to ERA (2008-2010)

ModII PD: CAM5.3-Oslo, 2000 emissions, 6 years spin-up, nudged to ERA (2004-2010)

ModII PI: Not available ---> anthropogenic fields are given zero values in the figures below...

Known bugs/shortcomings:

* ModI has some minor bugs (described at the top)

* Condensation/coagulation sink is (still) function of dry size


Emissions

Zonally averaged mass mixing ratios

Zonally averaged mode parameters

Burdens

Effective dry aerosol radii

Particular Matter (PM) concentrations (CAM5-Oslo vs. CAM5-Oslo only)

Wet to total deposition ratios

Lifetimes

RH, cloud properties and precipitation

Cloud droplet properties

Angstrom coefficient, aerosol optical depth, SSA and G

Aerosol optical depth for each species

Mass extinction coefficients for each species

Anthropogenic (PD - PI) aerosol and cloud/RH fields

Radiative forcings at top of the atmosphere

Radiative fluxes at top of the atmosphere


Mass budget numbers for ModI and ModII

(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SO2 total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 65.032, 65.032
(0)	SO2 total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 97.264, 97.304
(0)	SO2 total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 97.149, 97.186
(0)	SO2 burden            (Tg)                = 0.358, 0.359
(0)	SO2 wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 19.347, 19.522
(0)	SO2 lifetime          (d)                 = 1.343, 1.347
(0)	SO2 chemical loss     (%)                 = 58.304, 58.124
(0)	SO2 pct of chem loss in clear air (%)     = 24.773, 24.867
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SO4 total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 1.667, 1.667
(0)	SO4 total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 58.348, 58.204
(0)	SO4 total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 58.086, 57.923
(0)	SO4 burden            (Tg)                = 0.570, 0.580
(0)	SO4 wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 83.234, 86.834
(0)	SO4 lifetime          (d)                 = 3.584, 3.653
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	BC total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 7.928, 7.928
(0)	BC total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 7.928, 7.928
(0)	BC total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 7.917, 7.916
(0)	BC burden            (Tg)                 = 0.107, 0.107
(0)	BC wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 74.119, 75.279
(0)	BC lifetime          (d)                  = 4.948, 4.931
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	POM total emissions   (Tg/yr)             = 87.087, 87.105
(0)	POM total sources     (Tg/yr)             = 175.480, 176.248
(0)	POM total sink        (Tg/yr)             = 174.853, 175.589
(0)	POM burden            (Tg)                = 2.460, 2.474
(0)	POM wet depostion     (% of sinks)        = 83.220, 86.380
(0)	POM lifetime          (d)                 = 5.135, 5.142
(0)	POM chem prod from MSA (Tg/yr)            = 9.238, 9.259
(0)	POM chem prod (total) (Tg/yr)             = 88.393, 89.142
(0)	POM chem prod terpenes (Tg /yr)           = 79.155, 79.883
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	SS total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 1999.516, 2004.391
(0)	SS total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 1999.516, 2004.391
(0)	SS total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 1998.592, 2003.477
(0)	SS burden            (Tg)                 = 5.898, 5.904
(0)	SS wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 56.246, 56.307
(0)	SS lifetime          (d)                  = 1.077, 1.076
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	Mass budget numbers for model version      I (old), II (new)
(0)	Note: Values for DMS; SO2 and SO4 are given as Sulfur (S) values
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------
(0)	DU total emissions   (Tg/yr)              = 2774.588, 3027.218
(0)	DU total sources     (Tg/yr)              = 2774.588, 3027.218
(0)	DU total sink        (Tg/yr)              = 2771.635, 3024.263
(0)	DU burden            (Tg)                 = 17.548, 15.799
(0)	DU wet depostion     (% of sinks)         = 24.097, 19.548
(0)	DU lifetime          (d)                  = 2.311, 1.907
(0)	-------------------------------------------------------------